I recently had an issue with a bike that came in for an upgrade to the gearing so the owner could climb hills a bit easier. I had the view that Shimano is always consistent and that most parts are mix and match when it comes to pull ratios on the shifters. The bike had 10 speed Dura ace shifters and a short cage derailleur. I purchased a Tiagra 10 speed medium cage 4700 derailleur and proceeded with the upgrade. I spent hours trying to get the set up right, even engaged another mechanic to take a look and came to the conclusion that it would not work. I then found this article on mixing groupsets that was a great help confirming my fears that I had wasted lots of time trying to get a derailleur to work that had different ration pulls on the cable. If it had been Campagnolo I would have checked earlier!
